Most realistic movie execution rating
Forum Home  >  Public : General  >  Most realistic movie execution rating

Page:  1 
 
 
Which movie scene do you rate ad most realistic execution by different method ?

Hanging
Electric chair
Lethal injection
Firing squad

Lets see what everybody thinks
 
 
>Hanging

It's hard to argue with the hanging of Caroline Crale in "Five Little Pigs":

https://themiscollection.com/set/Pierrot_-_Five_Little_Pigs

(Honorable mentions go to "The Grand" and "Pierrepoint: The Last Hangman")
You need to be logged in to view attachments.
 
 
>Firing squad

The best of the various Mata Hari executions is "Mata Hari: La Vraie Histoire"

https://themiscollection.com/set/Mata_Hari_La_Vraie_Histoire_[ARTE]
 
 
Lethal Injection

Last Dance
 
 
Hanging

Other good ones are Cordelia, Milada Horakova [Earlier film], Ripper Street - 1st hanging, Town Called Hell, Great Train Robbery, Devils Whore & the execution of Lucy Diver in Moll Flanders
 
 
Electric Chair - Daniel

https://themiscollection.com/set/Daniel

Gas Chamber -I Want To Live (Susan Hayward version)

https://themiscollection.com/set/I_Want_to_Live!
 
 
Can i talk with you please necessary
 
 
Yes you are talking to me and everybody here
What do you want ?
 
 
Hanging:

Silver Tycoon is Great from the east.

Two good westerns:

1. Hel on wheels - Thirteen Stepas. One miss, hands are tied front, not back as should be.

2. Wagon Train - Pearlie Garnet story. Noosing and hanging off the screen but you hear sound of trapdoor and pinioning and all the preparations are Great. Lady on the gallows as well.
 
 
My favorite method is firing squads. Most are in my Folder

http://www.mediafire.com/folder/nnkh35o60lfm6/Firing_Squad

I have a preference for bound women, and blindfolds, so these are reflected in my rankings

1. Oscar Una PasionSurrealista

Hands tied behind back, and great lead up with a lot of shots of her as the squad readies and aims.

Nice impact shots.

Down sides, no blindfold (for me) and no body shots afterwards.

2. Lezáky 42

Best post execution with blindfolds of three women, hands tied behind.

Nice shot of impacts and pole slump.
I'd prefer more of a leadup, with shots of them being tied at the post, and the actual impact shots are a bit in-accurate.

3. Günah Bende Mi

Nice post execution of a Femme Fatale.
Great leadup, with her being tied to the post hands behind back, and good lead up, and slump.

Loses points for no blindfold, and her large coat which blocks some of the views of her tied hands

4. Five For Hell

Classic FS scene of Femme Fatale (Margaret Lee)

Hands tied behind beck and ankles tied, although shown in a wide shot so not much detail.

Good Shots of blindfold being tied, and waiting for the shots.

The fall is shown from a distance, but show her falling well with her hands and ankles tied.

Down sides also include the bad quality, which makes zooming in hard to do.

5. Mata Hari La Varie Histoire Arte

Best Mata Hari scene - she is tied to the post hands behind back (not that historically accurate)
Again no blindfold

Great build up where the charge is read to her while being tied up, nice impact shots, but she falls free of the stake when shot, so loses points for no pole slide/slump

6. Wish me luck (UK Tv series)

Nice FS execution by handgun, girl ties to post, and slump is shown afterwards.

Nice build up, although scene cuts just before being tied to the post, until the shots.

No squibs, but nice reaction as she slumps in her bonds

7. Bluebell (BBC series)

Nice shot of blindfold being tied while she is tied hands behind back to post, and the build up, including a view down the rifle.

Shot is OK, no squibs, just a reaction and slumping he in the post

8. Camila

Has a good leadup, blindfold, hands behind back.
Downsides are being carried - I like to see the woman doing her last walk, and the fact that she is seated.

The impact shots are excellent, with her falling and reacting in pain as the shots hit, and her expiring on the ground.

Also excellent body handling shots as she is placed in the coffin with her lover still bound and blindfolded.

9. The Other side of Midnight

No hands bound or blindofld, but good build up, with the woman being re-positioned to face the firing squad.
Nice expressions, and impact is shown at medium shot.

10. Knocks at My Door

Has all the components, hands tied and blindfold, but loses out due to image quality and the impact being shown in a wide shot, with no aftermath shot.

Honorable lead ups with execution.
I have tried to re-edited to change the ending

* The Fall

Good lead up, and nice woman.
There is an impact, so was amenable to re-editing.

* Viva Maria

Nice build up, with blindfolds and tied behind back and legs tied.
Also amenable to re-editing

* Benny Hill

Good build up (for a compedy!!!), with scanitly clad woman.

Blindfold (with her bra !!), and can be re-edited with some imagination.

* Red Dwarf - Stoke me a Clipper

Nice build up, with woman in red dress tied to post.
Can be re-edited to show desired outcome
 
 
I'm going with I Want to Live (1958) with Susan Hayward.
 
 
Xxxx ... i want to see private pictures
allWomen in Prison-institution
 
 

Quote by TaylorLethal Injection

Last Dance


I second that. I wish there was a scene where Sharon Stone puts on a diaper.


Page:  1 
Forum > Public / General > Most realistic movie execution rating

 
  Reply
You need to be logged in to reply.



Powered by Chloris [experimental m.b.]